From Prediction to Precision: Leveraging LLMs for Equitable and Data-Driven Writing Placement in Developmental Education

Accurate text classification and placement remain challenges in U.S. higher education, with traditional automated systems like Accuplacer functioning as "black-box" models with limited assessment transparency. This study evaluates Large Language Models (LLMs) as complementary placement tools by comparing their classification performance against a human-rated gold standard and Accuplacer. A 450-essay corpus was classified using Claude, Gemini, GPT-3.5-turbo, and GPT-4o across four prompting strategies: Zero-shot, Few-shot, Enhanced, and Enhanced+ (definitions with examples). Two classification approaches were tested: (i) a 1-step, 3 class classification task, distinguishing DevEd Level 1, DevEd Level 2, and…